Lindsey
Meet
I’m Lindsey Garito, and I found my way to a life and career that I lead intentionally and purposefully. And now I help others do the same.
With over two decades of progressive experience in human resources, I’ve worked with thousands of professionals — in hiring processes, performance conversations, mentorship journeys, and moments of personal and professional development.
I’ve built my professional career from starting out as an entry-level human resources coordinator to a successful HR executive leading high-performing, award-winning teams that drive innovation and transformation. I earned my BBA and MBA from Pace University, and I hold SHRM-SCP and SPHR certifications.
Beyond my corporate experience, I serve on boards and in volunteer leadership roles that keep me deeply connected to the broader community. I am President-Elect of the Westchester Human Resources Management Association (WHRMA) and serve on the Board of Directors for Greater Mental Health of New York. I also serve on the committee for DisruptHR Westchester County.
-
20 years of progressive Human Resources experience
15+ years in the healthcare industry
4 years in coaching & mentoring
-
2026 Excellence in Benefits Award through Employee Benefit News
2024 SHRM NYS Human Resources Professional of the Year
2023 Susan R. Meisinger Fellowship through SHRM Foundation
2022 Human Resources Today MVP Award for Workplace Wellness article
2021 Workday Process Innovation Award for innovative custom Total Rewards Dashboard
2020 Workday Process Innovation Award for creation of COVID-19 Resource Center and innovative use of technology
-
Bachelor of Business Administration from Pace University
Master of Business Administration from Pace University
Student at UT Dallas Professional and Executive Coaching Program
SPHR certified through HRCI
SHRM-SCP certified through SHRM
About Totally Rewarding
One of my favorite areas of human resources and my career is total rewards — where what makes work worthwhile goes so much deeper than a paycheck. Totally Rewarding™ was born from that same holistic philosophy. A truly fulfilling life is one where your career, relationships, mission and values, and sense of self all work together instead of against each other.
Through career and executive coaching, people and culture advisory, and speaking and workshops, Totally Rewarding offers the guidance, strategy, and support to help you achieve your goals. I meet you where you are — whether you’re just getting started in your career, a senior leader navigating professional growth, an organization building people strategy, or an aspiring entrepreneur.
For individuals navigating career decisions, leadership challenges, or major life transitions, coaching provides a dedicated space to gain clarity, build confidence, and move forward with intention. Whether you are early in your career, mid-career and ready for something more, or stepping into a new chapter entirely, the work starts with you and what you truly want.
And when individuals grow — when they step into their potential, lead with greater confidence, and show up more fully — the impact doesn’t stop with them. It ripples into their work, their teams, their organizations, and everyone they influence along the way.